Image by beasternchen for Pixabay
AI’s in the workplace. Whether it’s auto-generated emails, chatbots, or predictive analytics, AI’s here to stay. Plain and simple. Plain, perhaps — but not simple.
With its promises of greater efficiency and increased productivity, employers love AI. From the employees’ point of view, AI is a decidedly mixed blessing. But it’s killing workers’ motivation and engagement.
The Productivity Paradox
Of course AI can make tasks quicker. Harvard Business Review researchers found that while Gen AI bolsters task performance, it undermines intrinsic motivation, leaving workers feeling bored when switching to tasks without that AI boost. Another study reported an 11% dip in motivation and a 20% rise in boredom when employees moved away from AI-supported work.
AI’s short-term effect sharpens perfomance, but in the long run other tasks and responsibilities may feel dull and make us disengage.
The Psychological Toll
Workers feel uneasy, and it’s easy to understand why. A Gusto survey found that one-third of U.S. employees now consider AI essential, while one-quarter overstated their AI skills during hiring – a sure sign that workers are feeling pressure and uncertainty.
Fears about job security figure into this. Ernst & Young data shows 75% fear job loss due to AI and 65% worry their role might vanish entirely. That psychological strain is rooted in fears of obsolescence.
The Erosion of Workplace Connection
The global pandemic drove many of us endless doomscrolling and separated us from the friends and colleagues we used to have at an actual workplace. AI enhances this feeling of remoteness. Chatbots and auto-generated responses can replace human check-ins and isolate employees. Employers praised AI’s efficiency, but at the cost of weakened social bonds and dulled critical thinking.
The Financial Times warns that overusing tools like ChatGPT erodes mental health and compromises teamwork. When human connection fades, so does employee engagement.
Human-Centered Strategies
As with so many things, AI can be used wisely as a powerful tool. Here are some strategies organizations — and employees — can champion:
● Treat AI as a co-pilot, not autopilot – Teams must prioritize learning before leaning into AI too heavily.
● Embed employee feedback in AI implementation –When workers feel AI is designed for them, not to them, adoption and adaptation has skyrocketed by 32%.
● Train and upskill — don’t reduce tasks and projects – A supportive environment emphasizing growth, balance, and AI-enabled learning fuels motivation.
● Leverage AI to personalize experience. From internal communication to burnout indicators, AI can deliver timely, meaningful insights when used thoughtfully.
● Apply agentic AI to ease burnout, don’t displace people – In Southeast Asia, autonomous AI tools helped reduce workload stress by stepping in for repetitive tasks — lifting them up rather than replacing employees.
● Deploy AI coaching for growth – Hybrid platforms like BetterUp Grow blend AI with human coaching, improving confidence and engagement.
Final Thoughts
AI is marvelous as far as productivity goes, but it can crush the workers’ sense of autonomy, creativity, and collaboration. The key lies in intentional design, human-centric governance, and inclusive rollout strategies.
When used with transparency, purpose, and uplift, AI can be a genuine partner in the working world. But if used badly, it can damage any business’s true assets: happy, healthy workers who are committed to their jobs and take pride in what they do. AI has no pride. Borrowing a title from the English novelist Graham Greene, there’s one thing AI can’t replace: the human factor.
